| 🥇 | peanut butter, creamy | Legumes and Legume Products | 54.24 | 70% |
| 🥈 | peanut butter, creamy | Legumes and Legume Products | 53.37 | 68% |
| 🥉 | peanut butter, creamy | Legumes and Legume Products | 52.85 | 68% |
| 4 | Proximates, Peanut butter, creamy, JIF (MI,OK) - NFY120CAP | Legumes and Legume Products | 52.7 | 68% |
| 5 | peanut butter, creamy | Legumes and Legume Products | 52.6 | 67% |
| 6 | Proximates, Peanut butter, creamy, store brand/other brand, AMERICAS CHOICE & GREAT VALUE (NY) - NFY120CB3 | Legumes and Legume Products | 52.5 | 67% |
| 7 | Proximates, Peanut butter, creamy, JIF (AL,CA1) - NFY120C96 | Legumes and Legume Products | 52.2 | 67% |
| 8 | Proximates, Peanut butter, creamy, JIF (IN,NY) - NFY120C8R | Legumes and Legume Products | 52 | 67% |
| 9 | Proximates, Peanut butter, creamy, JIF (CA2,NC) - NFY120C9J | Legumes and Legume Products | 51.8 | 66% |
| 10 | Proximates, Peanut butter, creamy, store brand/other brand, SAFEWAY KITCHENS & SHOP RITE (CO,CT) - NFY120CD2 | Legumes and Legume Products | 51.8 | 66% |
| 11 | Proximates, Peanut butter, creamy, JIF (CO,CT) - NFY120C9W | Legumes and Legume Products | 51.7 | 66% |
| 12 | peanut butter, creamy | Legumes and Legume Products | 51.48 | 66% |
| 13 | Proximates, Peanut butter, creamy, JIF (FL,MO) - NFY120CAA | Legumes and Legume Products | 51.4 | 66% |
| 14 | Proximates, Peanut butter, creamy, store brand/other brand, KROGER (IN,MI) - NFY120CCA | Legumes and Legume Products | 51.2 | 66% |
| 15 | Peanut butter, smooth style, with salt | Legumes and Legume Products | 51.1 | 66% |
| 16 | Proximates, Peanut butter, creamy, store brand/other brand, HYVEE & PUBLIX (FL,MO) - NFY120CCO | Legumes and Legume Products | 51 | 65% |
| 17 | Proximates, Peanut butter, creamy, SKIPPY (AL,CA1) - NFY120C6T | Legumes and Legume Products | 50.8 | 65% |
| 18 | Proximates, Peanut butter, creamy, SKIPPY (IN,NY) - NFY120C6F | Legumes and Legume Products | 50.4 | 65% |
| 19 | Proximates, Peanut butter, creamy, SKIPPY (CO,CT) - NFY120C7L | Legumes and Legume Products | 50.3 | 65% |
| 20 | Proximates, Peanut butter, creamy, SKIPPY (MI) - NFY120C7Y | Legumes and Legume Products | 50.2 | 64% |
| 21 | Proximates, Peanut butter, creamy, store brand/other brand, GREAT VALUE (AL,OK) - NFY120CBI | Legumes and Legume Products | 50.2 | 64% |
| 22 | Proximates, Peanut butter, creamy, SKIPPY (CA2,NC) - NFY120C77 | Legumes and Legume Products | 50.1 | 64% |
| 23 | Proximates, Peanut butter, creamy, store brand/other brand, MY ESSENTIALS & SUNNY SELECT (CA2,NC) - NFY120CBW | Legumes and Legume Products | 50 | 64% |
| 24 | Proximates, Peanut butter, creamy, SKIPPY (FL,MO) - NFY120C8D | Legumes and Legume Products | 49.7 | 64% |
| 25 | Peanut butter, creamy | Legumes and Legume Products | 49.43 | 63% |
| 26 | peanut butter, creamy | Legumes and Legume Products | 48.93 | 63% |
| 27 | peanuts, raw | Legumes and Legume Products | 48.52 | 62% |
| 28 | peanut butter, creamy | Legumes and Legume Products | 48.49 | 62% |
| 29 | peanuts, raw | Legumes and Legume Products | 47.27 | 61% |
| 30 | peanuts, raw | Legumes and Legume Products | 44.76 | 57% |